Welcome to my genealogy blog. Genea-Musings features genealogy research tips and techniques, genealogy news items and commentary, genealogy humor, San Diego genealogy society news, family history research and some family history stories from the keyboard of Randy Seaver (of Chula Vista CA), who thinks that Genealogy Research Is really FUN! Copyright (c) Randall J. Seaver, 2006-2024.
Saturday, June 26, 2010
Saturday Night Genealogy Fun - Why Do Genealogy?
Your mission, should you decide to accept it, is to:
1) Think about the question: "Why do I pursue genealogy and family history research?"
2) Tell us about it on your own blog post, in a comment to this blog post, or in a comment on Facebook.
This question was prompted by a current ongoing discussion on the APG Public mailing List about celebrities and their relationship to royalty of famous historical persons. There are some excellent responses in this mailing list thread.
Here's why I pursue genealogy and family history research:
1) To honor the effort and lives of my ancestors.
2) To put my life into a historical perspective.
3) It is intellectually challenging and stimulating, and serious fun!
Surname Saturday - HORTON (of Eastham MA)
My hypothesis is that the mother of Elizabeth Horton Dill is not Mary Horton, but is really Hannah Horton (1761-1797), who married Thomas Dill on 18 May 1782 in Wellfleet MA. Thomas and Hannah (Horton) Dill had nine children (Ezekiel, Obediah, Seth, Isaiah, Jabez, Elizabeth, James, Daniel and Asa Dill between 1784 and 1795), and Hannah apparently died before June 1797 when Thomas Dill married Ruth Linkhornew.
I have described my evidence conflicts for this case in my post Elizabeth Horton Dill: A Very Elusive Ancestor. If she is indeed the Elizabeth Dill, born 09 May 1791 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA, the daughter of Thomas Dill and Hannah Horton, then my potential ancestral line back through four generations of HORTONs is:
1. Randall J. Seaver
2. Frederick W. Seaver (1911-1983)
3. Betty V. Carringer (1919-2002)
4. Frederick W. Seaver (1876-1942)
5. Alma Bessie Richmond (1882-1962)
8. Frank W. Seaver (1852-1922)
9. Harriet Hildreth (1857-1920)
16. Isaac Seaver (1823-1901)
17. Lucretia Townsend Smith (1827-1884)
34. Alpheus B. Smith (1802-1840)
35. Elizabeth Horton Dill (1794-1869)
[and then the hypothesis fits right here... Elizabeth Horton Dill was daughter of Thomas and Hannah (Horton) Dill]
70. Thomas Dill, born 18 May 1782 in Wellfleet, Barnstable, MA. He was born about 1755 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA, and died after 1830 in probably Eastham, Barnstable, MA. He was the son of Thomas Dill and Mehitable Brown. He married (1) 18 May 1782 in Wellfleet, Barnstable, MA.
71. Hannah Horton, born 28 April 1761 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA; died before 1797 in probably Eastham, Barnstable, MA.
142. Nathaniel Horton, born 24 February 1720/21 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA; died Bef. May 1775 in prob. Eastham, Barnstable, MA. He married 10 January 1741/42 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA.
143. Eunice Snow, born 30 November 1722 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA. She was the daughter of 286. Jabez Snow and 287. Elizabeth Paine.
Children of Nathaniel Horton and Eunice Snow are: Elnathan Horton (1743-????); Nathaniel Horton (1746-????); Obadiah Horton (1747-????); William Horton (1750-????); Elizabeth Horton (1753-????); James Horton (1755-????); Eunice Horton (1757-????); Jabez Horton (1759-1759); Hannah Horton (1761-1797); Anna Horton (1763-????).
284. Samuel Horton, born 31 January 1685/86 in Boston, Suffolk, MA; died before 01 April 1778 in Eastham, Barnstable County, MA. He married 28 January 1713/14 in Eastham, Barnstable County, MA.
285. Hannah Atwood, born about 1680 in Eastham, Barnstable County, MA. She was the daughter of 570. Stephen Atwood and 571. Apphia Bangs.
Children of Samuel Horton and Hannah Atwood are: John Horton (1715-????); Hannah Horton (1717-????); Nathaniel Horton (1721-1775); Susanna Horton (1723-????); Abigail Horton (1725-????); Elizabeth Horton (1727-????); Samuel Horton (1729-1799); James Horton (1731-????).
568. John Horton, born about 1650, died before 06 April 1710 in Eastham, Barnstable, MA. He married before 1677
569. Hannah, died 07 January 1689/90 in Boston, Suffolk, MA.
Children of John Horton and Hannah are: Dorothy Horton (????-????); Hopestill Horton (1677-????); Samuel Horton (1686-1778).
The line ends with John Horton. There was some discussion many years ago that this John Horton that had at least one child in Boston in 1686 and died in Eastham in 1710 was a descendant of Thomas Horton of Rehoboth MA, or of Ralph or John Houghton of Lancaster MA. I've consulted the available books for those two families, and do not find a candidate to be the John Horton (or Houghton) of Eastham. A brief search using Google and Rootsweb WorldConnect databases did not provide any revelations. This John Horton of Boston and Eastham is listed in several databases, with a wife named Hannah ????, Hannah Harden and Hannah Long.
If any researcher has more up-to-date information about this John Horton (or Houghton) of Boston and Eastham, I would appreciate hearing from you. Are there any cousins with this Horton family in Eastham MA - I would appreciate hearing from you also! My email is rjseaver@cox.net.
UPDATED: It appears that there is a book about this family: "Descendants of John Horton of Boston, Massachusetts and New London, Connecticut through his son Samuel Horton of Eastham, Massachusetts" by Margaret Horton Weiler published by Penobscot Press, 1994. Now on my "To Find" list!
Friday, June 25, 2010
What's Cooking at FamilySearch.org? GIGO?
There is more news from the LDS FamilySearch website about the new Family Tree online database. I was reading Renee Zamora's Renee's Genealogy Blog post titled nFS June release beta includes new features, discussion boards, etc. from last week, and she noted that several new features were coming soon, including:
"The biggest one is 'Discussion boards'. Behind each ancestor will be a discussion board, sort of like a talk page on a wiki, where one can discuss what they are doing or what they need to find in regards to that ancestor."
"The next feature is 'exact search', you will need to have several of the fields filled out to activate this. There will also be some things with the standardized places to allow for defunct places that are not yet in the database to be added."
Renee included a link to the http://ftbeta.familysearch.org/ site to see more about the Discussion Boards, but the link doesn't work for me now. I found a 7-page PDF for the June 2010 What's New information. Please read all of Renee's post.
James Tanner, on the Genealogy's Star blog, recently wrote Waiting for the shoe to drop in New FamilySearch about the Discussion Boards, and he noted that:
"The newest version of New FamilySearch implements the individual "Discussion Board." This is sort-of a mini-forum available for each individual. The announcement of the implementation says:
"* Each deceased individual in the system has a discussion board, where you can do the following:
* Identify yourself as someone who is interested in or actively working on an individual or family line.
* Coordinate the correction of errors and additional research with other interested users.
* Identify incorrect information on the individual’s record."
Please read all of his post. James' closing paragraph is:
"It will be interesting to see if the new discussion feature has an impact on the amount of poorly researched and inaccurate information being loaded into the program. One of the most obvious issues with the new discussion tab is that there is nothing in the program indicating that there is discussion going on. It is likely that the same people who do not take the time to edit or review their inaccurate entries will not take the time to read the discussions either. I am putting out a few discussions to see if anyone reads them."
That sure doesn't give me a lot of confidence that the new FamilySearch Family Tree will be much better than the current Ancestral File, Pedigree Resource File and IGI cobbled together! It sounds like GIGO - Garbage in, Garbage Out - to me.
The impression I had from all of the nifty FamilySearch presentations at NGS 2010 and SCGS 2010 was that the duplicates were being combined and the general public would be invited late in 2010 or in early 2011 to contribute their family tree data. The "One Big Mother of all Family Trees" was almost ready to go!
James identifies the big problem with using the existing data in the nFS Family Tree database in his post What is going into New FamilySearch? He concludes his post with:
"In this regard, the latest change to the program initiated a Discussion tab for each individual. Other than the fact that there is nothing in the program indicating that a discussion is available, this is at least a possible step in the right direction. But it does not address the core problem of the multiplicity of inaccurate information flooding into the program. "
Is the nFS Family Tree database destined to go the route of almost all other large family tree databases (whether merged or separate)? They have many duplicate entries and wrong information for many persons.
The Discussion Boards sound like a wonderful idea in theory. I truly hope that they will work as intended. I wrote about the use of Footnote Pages to capture evidence and resources about individuals during the NGS Conference, and mentioned something like the Discussion Boards. But what if they don't work as intended? Does FamilySearch have a fallback position if they don't work as expected?
The one online family tree database that I'm aware of that has some sort of editorial control over duplicate persons, and information for those persons, is the WeRelate family tree wiki at http://www.werelate.org/. When I added persons to the database, I had to manually merge persons in my tree with persons in the existing database that were probably the same persons before it would let me upload my tree data. For some persons, mainly those with many descendants that submitted family trees (e.g., Mayflower passengers, connections to European royalty, etc.), the information about them was standardized and "fixed" by designated editors or monitors, and changes to the information can only be done by discussion and agreement between the submitters and the editors/monitors.
Perhaps FamilySearch will have to take the decisions about what is "alleged" about a specific person in their Family Tree database out of the hands of the contributors and create some sort of mediation or arbitration board that decides facts based on the available evidence brought to the discussion by the contributors. That sounds like many lifetimes of hard work that may cause a lot of hard feelings and arguments. But it may be the ultimate best solution that bases judgments on facts and evidence rather than unsupported data.
As you probably know, I am not a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, and do not have access to the new FamilySearch Family Tree database. I am really interested in what is going to happen with the nFS Family Tree database because many non-LDS researchers will be tempted to search it for research clues and may add their family tree data to the database.
My thanks to Renee and James, and to The Ancestry Insider, for sharing their information about the nFS Family Tree changes. Who will be the first genea-blogger to show what the Discussion Boards look like and how they work?
Follow Friday - We Tree blog

Amy's blog sub-title is "Adventures in Genealogy." Her "About Me" paragraph includes:
"Welcome to my blog, where I chronicle my own adventures in genealogy and hopefully inspire you to do the same. "
Amy is also the creator of the 52 Weeks To Better Genealogy - a series of weekly blogging prompts that are a bit more challenging and are geared towards those new to the field of genealogy and family history, as well as those who want to brush up on some skills which might be a bit rusty.
If you are not reading Amy's blog, I encourage you to add her to your list of favorities, bookmarks, RSS feed, blog aggregator or email reader.
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Is Robert Pattinson a cousin to Vlad III Dracula?
A screen shot of the Ancestry.co.uk blog page is shown below, and it includes a simple ancestry chart:

There is only one thing wrong with this picture - remember the adage that "the cousin of my cousin may not be my cousin!" Just because Barack Obama is my cousin doesn't not mean that all of my cousins are also his cousins - only those that share my specific lineage back to a common ancestor are his cousins.
The common definition of a "cousin" is a person with a common ancestor to the subject.
If the information in the picture is correct, then Robert Pattinson is a distant cousin of the Princes. and the Princes are a distant cousin to Vlad III Dracula. But Robert Pattinson and Vlad II Dracula are not distant cousins because no common ancestor is shown on the chart.
If Ancestry.co.uk has more specific direct evidence with primary information from original sources concerning the ancestry of Robert Pattinson and Vlad III Dracula, then they should display it for the world of genealogy to see it. Until then, they should remove the claim.
For the genealogists of the world, a better ancestral chart showing all of the generations from the "Pickerings of York" to the Princes and from Vlad's parents to King George VI should also be shown so that the degree of cousinship with the Princes can be established. Proof of all of the relationships would be nice, too.
Searching Ancestry.com Newspapers Using Keywords
I was trolling through the online newspapers at www.Ancestry.com and found a "better way" to search for my people. This may fall into the "you already knew this, but I just found out" category, but that's OK - there may be some Ancestry.com users in the vast (yeah, right!) Genea-Musings readership that could use the information to make the searching task easier or better, especially for common names.
In the past, I have always put first name and last name in the search fields when I've searched Newspaper and Book collections on Ancestry.com. I received an email today that said "have you looked at keyword searches?" Ummm, no, not really.
I started out on the Newspaper Collection page on Ancestry.com - and there was a helpful link to a Juliana Smith article from 2009 titled "Searching for Newspaper Stories." This article suggested that:
"Typically when searching for a person, it’s best to leave the “Match all terms exactly” box unchecked. This allows us a little wiggle room, but when searching for common terms, it’s easy to become overrun with results. For keyword searches it’s helpful to keep that “Match all terms” box checked. (Just bear in mind that when you go back to searching for people, you’ll want to uncheck this box again.)"
and:
"Remember that if you want to search for several words together, you can put them in quotes which will tell Ancestry.com to look for that exact phrase (e.g., “cholera epidemic”)."
Read the whole article - it helps! Here's a screen shot of the article page:

To illustrate the differences between a Name Search, using names in the first and last name search fields, and using a Keyword Search, I'm going to use my grandfather's name, Frederick Seaver. For the Name Search, I entered First Name = "Fred*" (because he went by Fred and Frederick) and Last Name = "Seaver." I clicked on "Restrict to Exact" for both names. The Search fields are shown below:

I received 341 matches from my Name Search, in a number of newspapers:

The Fitchburg (MA) Sentinel was one of the local newspapers for Leominster MA, so I clicked on that link, and saw 53 matches:

The results page above has snippets showing one or more matches on a given page. When you look at the matches produced by the Name Search, you see that not all of the matches are for Fred* Seaver. Some matches are for a page with Seaver in one place and Fred* in a nearby place on the page. Some of the matches found using the Name Search are for Frederick W. Seaver, which I definitely want to find.

I clicked on the Fitchburg Sentinel link again and saw:

There were only 26 matches for the "fred* seaver" Keyword Search, and all of them were for my "Fred* Seaver" or his wife listed as "Mrs. Fred* Seaver." However, none of the matches for Frederick W. Seaver are listed. Drat! I did another search for "fred* w seaver" in the Keyword Search and there were 16 matches.
Treasure Chest Thursday - a Hildreth+Newton Marriage Record
This week, it is the Marriage Certificate of Edward Hildreth (1831-1899) and Sophia Newton (1834-1923) in Northborough, Middlesex County, Massachusetts on 25 December 1852:

Wednesday, June 23, 2010
"Using Ancestry.com Effectively" Talk on Sunday, 27 June in Chula Vista CA
The Board of the Chula Vista Genealogical Society recently decided to provide Sunday afternoon programs for members and others who cannot attend the Wednesday daytime meetings.
The first Sunday program will have CVGS Member Randy Seaver presenting "Using Ancestry.com Effectively."
This talk will be at 2 p.m. to 4 p.m. on Sunday, June 27th, in the Auditorium of the Chula Vista Civic Center Branch Library (365 F Street in downtown Chula Vista).
The talk summary is:
The Ancestry.com subscription website has many wonderful features - it's like a lavish buffet where it is hard to choose what to do and how to use it.
o For searches: basic or advanced search; new or old search screens; exact or ranked matches; full names or wild cards; specific or all databases; name and place filters; restricted collection or whole collection.
o For family trees: public or private; one-editor or group editors; GEDCOM upload or enter-by-hand; upload photos and documents; attach historical documents; add stories; "collect" data from others; synchronization with software; etc.
In this presentation, Randy will discuss and demonstrate these issues and offer recommendations for effectively using Ancestry.com databases and family trees.
Randy Seaver is a former President of CVGS, and is the current Newsletter Editor and Research Chairman. He also writes the Genealogy 2.0 column in the quarterly FGS FORUM Magazine and is well-known in national genealogy circles through his Genea-Musings genealogy blog. Randy has 22 years experience in genealogy research and has been doing online research since 1992.
All meetings of CVGS are free for members and non-members to attend. We welcome guests and visitors, and hope that you will want to join our active society. Flyers that announce all of our scheduled programs are placed in libraries, senior centers and other places around the San Diego South Bay area.
For more information about CVGS, or about this presentation, please contact Randy by phone (619-422-3397) or email (rjseaver@cox.net).
(Not So) Wordless Wednesday - Post 108: San Diego Carringers
I managed to scan about 100 family photographs in the Scanfest in January, and have converted the scanned TIF files to smaller JPGs, cropped and rotated as best I can. Many of these were "new" to my digital photograph collection.
Here is a photograph from the Carringer family collection handed down by my mother in the 1988 to 2002 time period:

My grandfather's writing on the back of this photograph says it was taken in 1939. Pictured here are (from the left):
* Harvey Edgar Carringer (1852-1946); brother of Henry Austin Carringer; never married, resided in San Diego
* Della (Smith) Carringer (1862-1944), wife of Henry Austin Carringer, mother of Lyle Carringer
* Henry Austin Carringer (1853-1946), husband of Della Smith, father of Lyle Carringer
* Lyle Lawrence Carringer (1891-1976), son of Henry Austin and Della (Smith) Carringer - my maternal grandfather.
I am unsure of the setting of this photograph. It looks like a back or side yard. My best guess is that this was taken in the back yard of the Lyle Carringer home at 2130 Fern Street in San Diego.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010
Who's #29,849? The Least "Popular" Ancestry.com Databases?
While wandering around Ancestry.com on Tuesday, I saw the list of "databases by Popularity" in the Ancestry.com Card Catalog. I wondered what were the "least popular." After a period of moving page by page (believe me, I tried every trick I could think of - at least I was able to go 10 pages at a time) to the last screen of the "Most Popular" databases, I came across the page with numbers 29,826 to 29,849. Here is the bottom of that page:

The "least popular" database, at least according to the "by popularity" list, is "Newport illustrated: in a series of pen & pencil sketches."
The Ancestry database has no description of this work. The Ancestry.com source citation says:
"Ancestry.com. Newport illustrated : in a series of pen & pencil sketches [database on-line]. Provo, UT: The Generations Network, Inc., 2005.
Original data: Mason, George C.. Newport illustrated : in a series of pen & pencil sketches. New York: D. Appleton & Co., c1854."
Here is the database page for this database:
The good news is that, with this post and anybody else that checked it out after reading this blog post, that it won't be at the bottom of the list in the near future. But it will still be unread by almost every researcher that uses Ancestry.com!
The next one up from the bottom on the list is #29,848 - "The Bottskill Baptist Church."
The Ancestry.com citation for this book is:
"Ancestry.com. The Bottskill Baptist Church [database on-line]. Provo, UT: The Generations Network, Inc., 2004.
Original data: Wade, Stuart C.. The Bottskill Baptist Church : Greenwich, Washington Co., N.Y. : copy of all tombstone inscriptions existing in 1901. unknown, 1989."
My guess is that there are hundreds of genealogy researchers that would love to have a look at this book, but they don't know that it is available on Ancestry.com. Now when they do a Google search, they may find this post and know that it is available.
There are 118 pages in this book on Ancestry.com (and I don't think that the book is complete...). There must be many more names than the 116 records noted in the list of "by popularity." Hmmm, perhaps the 116 is then umber of pages and this database, this book, is not name indexed at all.
So the lessons learned here, for me, are:
* Ancestry.com apparently has many (hundreds, thousands?) "databases" that are not indexed by every name, and nobody knows about them because of the lack of a name index for them.


