After I wrote Ask AI: Describe Lyle Carringer's Life At Age 23 in San Diego, California in 1915, I realized that there was much more to be told about my grandfather. He was age 24 in early 1916 and had many interests. But,. most importantly, how did he meet my grandmother?
Based on what I knew about his life (see ABC Biography of #6 Lyle Lawrence Carringer (1891-1976) of San Diego, California), I prompted my AI assistant Anthropic Claude to tell me stories about the next few years after providing some known details. Here is one story:
(AI Google NotebookLM Infographic - Lyle Carringer finds courage)
Finding Courage: Lyle Carringer, 1916-1917
Spring 1916 - The Teasing Begins
"All work and no play makes Lyle a dull boy!" Charlie Morrison called across the stockroom at Marston's Department Store, grinning as he tossed a rolled-up invoice at twenty-four-year-old Lyle Carringer.
Lyle caught it reflexively, his face flushing. "I have plenty of fun," he protested, though even to his own ears the words sounded weak.
"Oh yeah? When was the last time you went anywhere besides home and work?" his friend Eddie chimed in. "The Exposition closed four months ago, and I haven't seen you at a single party since then."
It was true. Since the Panama-California Exposition had ended in January, Lyle had thrown himself into his work at Marston's with single-minded dedication. Now a floorwalker after eleven years with the company, he took his responsibilities seriously—perhaps too seriously, his coworkers suggested.
"Come on, Lyle," Charlie said more gently. "We're not trying to give you a hard time. It's just...you're young. You should be out having fun, meeting people, maybe even...you know...talking to girls."
Lyle's flush deepened. At 5'7" and barely 125 pounds, with his slight build and youthful face, he'd always felt self-conscious around young women. Most of the girls he'd known in high school—he'd graduated in 1914—seemed to prefer taller, more athletic fellows. The kind of guys who'd played on San Diego High School's championship football team in 1916, not quiet bookkeepers who rode the trolley to work every day.
"I talk to girls," he muttered. "I talk to the sales clerks here all the time."
Eddie and Charlie exchanged knowing looks. "That's different," Eddie said. "That's work. We mean actually talking to girls. At parties. Maybe even...dancing."
The word "dancing" made Lyle's stomach flip. He'd never been much of a dancer. At the few high school events he'd attended, he'd mostly stood against the wall, watching others glide across the floor with an ease he couldn't imagine possessing.
Summer 1916 - First Steps
But his friends were persistent. Throughout the late spring and early summer of 1916, they kept inviting him to gatherings at their homes. Many of his former high school classmates from the Class of 1914 were still in San Diego, and house parties had become the preferred form of entertainment for young people their age.
"It's just a few people," Charlie assured him when extending the first invitation. "Nothing fancy. Just music on the Victrola, some refreshments, conversation. You don't have to dance if you don't want to."
That first party, in mid-June, was torture. Lyle arrived at Charlie's family home on a warm Saturday evening, his collar feeling too tight, his palms sweating. The living room was full of people his age—former classmates, their siblings, friends from work. And yes, several young women.
He managed to find a corner where he could observe without being too conspicuous. The Victrola played ragtime music, and couples danced in the cleared space in the center of the room. Others clustered in small groups, talking and laughing with an ease Lyle envied.
"Lyle! There you are!" Charlie appeared at his elbow with a pretty girl in tow. "This is my cousin Helen. She just moved here from Los Angeles. Helen, this is Lyle Carringer—he works at Marston's, been there since he was a kid."
Helen smiled warmly. "How nice to meet you, Mr. Carringer. Charlie's told me all about the famous Marston's. I'll have to come visit."
Lyle's mouth went dry. "Yes, you...you should. We have very fine goods. Quality merchandise at...at fair prices."
He sounded like he was reciting an advertisement. Helen's smile didn't waver, but he could see the slight puzzlement in her eyes. Fortunately, someone called her name from across the room, and she excused herself with a gracious nod.
"Well, that went well," Charlie said drily once she was gone.
"I know," Lyle groaned. "I sounded like an idiot."
"You sounded like a catalog. But hey, it's a start. You actually talked to her, right? That's progress!"
Fall 1916 - Building Confidence
Over the summer and into fall, Lyle continued accepting invitations to house parties. Slowly, painfully, he began to relax. He discovered that if he focused on listening rather than trying to think of clever things to say, conversations flowed more naturally. Young women seemed to appreciate someone who actually paid attention to what they were saying rather than just waiting for his turn to talk.
At a party in mid-October, he found himself in a conversation with two young women about the war in Europe. American involvement seemed increasingly likely, and everyone had opinions about President Wilson's policies.
"My brother says we'll be in it by spring," one of the girls said. "He's thinking about enlisting in the Marines before they draft him."
Lyle surprised himself by offering his own thoughts. "The Marines have been recruiting heavily in San Diego. We see them downtown all the time, in their dress uniforms. Very impressive."
"Would you enlist if we went to war?" the other girl asked, studying him with genuine interest.
The question caught him off guard. He hadn't really thought about it seriously. "I...I suppose I would. It would be the right thing to do, wouldn't it? To serve your country?"
"That's very noble," the first girl said, and Lyle felt a warmth spread through his chest at the admiration in her voice.
Later that evening, emboldened by ginger ale and the success of that conversation, Lyle even attempted to dance. It was a disaster—he stepped on his partner's toes twice and lost count of the steps completely—but she laughed good-naturedly and told him he just needed practice.
"The trick is to relax," she said. "You're thinking too hard about it. Just feel the music."
December 1916 - Growing Comfort
By December, house parties had become a regular part of Lyle's social calendar. He was still shy, still awkward at times, but his friends had stopped teasing him about being a hermit. He'd discovered that he actually enjoyed these gatherings—the music, the conversation, the sense of belonging to a group of young people navigating the same uncertain world.
The war in Europe loomed large in everyone's thoughts. The Panama-California Exposition had ended the previous January, but San Diego had been transformed by it. The Navy presence was growing, and military men were increasingly visible around the city. Everyone sensed that big changes were coming.
At a Christmas party, Lyle managed an entire conversation with a young woman named Minnie without once sounding like a Marston's catalog. They talked about their families, their work, their hopes for the future. Minnie was training to be a teacher, and she spoke passionately about education's importance.
"It's not just about facts and figures," she explained, her eyes bright. "It's about opening young minds to possibilities they might never have imagined."
Lyle found himself drawn in by her enthusiasm. "That's how I feel about my work," he said. "Not everyone understands, but there's real satisfaction in keeping careful records, in making sure everything balances. It's like...creating order out of chaos."
She nodded thoughtfully. "I can see that. There's artistry in precision, isn't there?"
When she asked him to dance, he didn't refuse. This time, he only stepped on her toes once.
January 1917 - An Unexpected Invitation
On a cold January evening, Charlie Morrison stopped by Lyle's house on 30th Street with an unusual proposition.
"My little brother Frank has a problem," Charlie said, settling into a chair in the Carringer parlor. Lyle's parents, Henry and Della, had retired to bed early, leaving the young men to talk.
"What kind of problem?"
"He and his friends are going to a dance at the high school Friday night, but they're short on fellows. You know how it is—there are always more girls than boys at these things. Frank asked if I knew anyone who might want to come along."
Lyle blinked. "A high school dance? Charlie, I'm twenty-five years old."
"I know, I know. But Frank's desperate. And besides..." Charlie grinned. "You look young. With that slight build of yours, you could pass for eighteen easy. Nobody would question it."
"That's ridiculous. I graduated in 1914!"
"From a different high school era," Charlie countered. "Most of the current students won't remember you. And the ones who do will just think you're helping out. Come on, Lyle. It's just one evening. Frank says the music's good, and there really are way more girls than boys. You'd actually be doing them a favor."
Lyle hesitated. The idea was absurd. And yet...after months of house parties, he'd grown more comfortable in social situations. A high school dance might actually be...fun?
"I don't know..."
"When was the last time someone needed you to do something social?" Charlie pressed. "Usually it's the other way around—people dragging you places. Here's a chance to actually help someone out. Frank's a good kid. He'll appreciate it."
Against his better judgment, Lyle heard himself say, "Alright. I'll go."
Friday, January 19, 1917 - The High School Dance
Friday evening found Lyle standing in front of his mirror, adjusting his bow tie for the third time. He'd chosen his newest suit, the one that made him look slightly less thin, and slicked his brown hair back neatly. His mother had raised an eyebrow when he'd mentioned going to a high school dance, but she hadn't objected.
"You look very handsome, dear," Della Carringer said from his doorway. "It's nice to see you going out so much lately."
"It's probably a terrible idea," Lyle muttered, but he was smiling as he said it.
Charlie and his brother Frank came by at seven o'clock. Frank Morrison was seventeen, tall and gangly, with the same friendly grin as his older brother.
"Thanks for doing this, Mr. Carringer," Frank said earnestly. "Charlie told me you're a swell dancer."
Lyle shot Charlie a look. "He told you what?"
"Well, you're improving," Charlie said diplomatically. "That's what matters."
They took the streetcar to San Diego High School, the impressive building that stood on the southern edge of Balboa Park. Lyle hadn't been back since his graduation nearly three years ago, and the sight of it stirred unexpected nostalgia. The 1916 football team had won the state championship—he'd read about it in the papers—and the school seemed to have a new energy about it.
Music drifted from the gymnasium as they approached. Inside, the space had been decorated with crepe paper streamers and lanterns. A small band played on a raised platform at one end, and clusters of young people filled the floor—couples dancing, groups of girls chatting together, a few boys standing awkwardly near the punch bowl.
"See?" Frank said quietly. "Way more girls than boys. They'll be thrilled to have another dance partner."
He was right. The ratio was immediately obvious. For every young man, there seemed to be at least two or three young women, many of them watching the door hopefully each time it opened.
"Come on," Charlie said, steering them toward the punch bowl. "Let's get our bearings."
The Dance Begins
The punch was overly sweet and faintly warm, but Lyle barely tasted it. His eyes swept the gymnasium, taking in the scene. The band was playing a waltz, and couples moved gracefully across the polished floor. The girls wore light-colored dresses in the current style—simple lines, dropped waists, modest hems that showed their ankles. The boys wore suits or at least good trousers and pressed shirts.
A group of girls near them were whispering and giggling, casting glances in their direction. One of them, a blonde with bright blue eyes, caught Lyle's eye and smiled before quickly looking away.
"Go ask her to dance," Charlie murmured.
"I don't even know her name."
"So introduce yourself. That's how it works."
Before Lyle could protest further, Frank had approached the group of girls. "Excuse me, ladies. My brother Charlie and his friend Lyle just arrived. Would any of you care to dance?"
The blonde stepped forward immediately. "I'd love to," she said, looking directly at Lyle.
And just like that, Lyle found himself walking onto the dance floor with a girl whose name he didn't yet know, the music swelling around them, his heart pounding in his chest.
"I'm Lyle Carringer," he managed as they took their positions.
"I know," she said, her blue eyes twinkling. "Frank just told us. I'm Bertha. Bertha Pruitt. I saw you at my sister’s dance party at Christmas."
A Moment Suspended
Lyle placed his hand carefully on Bertha's waist, trying to remember everything he'd learned at the house parties over the past months. His other hand found hers, and he was surprised by how naturally they fit together despite his nervousness.
"Are you in Frank's class?" he asked as they began to move.
"Junior," she said. "I'm only seventeen. What about you? Are you a senior?"
For a split second, Lyle considered lying. But something in those bright blue eyes made him want to tell the truth. "Actually, I graduated in 1914. I work at Marston's Department Store. I'm just here helping Frank out because there aren't enough boys."
He braced himself for her reaction—embarrassment, perhaps, or disappointment that he'd misled her. But Bertha just laughed, a warm, musical sound that made him smile despite his anxiety.
"That's very kind of you," she said. "Most fellows wouldn't be caught dead at a high school dance if they didn't have to be here."
"Well, I...I've been practicing," he admitted. "Dancing, I mean. I wasn't very good before."
"You're doing fine now," she assured him. "Much better than some of the boys here. Half of them just shuffle around and count under their breath."
They danced in silence for a moment, and Lyle was surprised to find that he was actually following the music, that his feet were moving in time with hers without him having to think about it constantly. She was right—he was getting better.
"So you work at Marston's?" Bertha asked. "What do you do there?"
"I'm a floorwalker," Lyle said. "I supervise the sales clerks, help customers, keep track of inventory, things like that. I've been there since I was fourteen—started as a cash boy."
"Fourteen! That's very young."
"My family needed the income," Lyle explained. "And I liked it. I still do. There's something satisfying about keeping everything organized, making sure things run smoothly."
Bertha nodded thoughtfully. "My friend Emily works there too. She lives with her mother, and it helps to have the extra income. There's no shame in honest work.”
Something about the way she said it—matter-of-fact, without judgment—made Lyle's chest loosen. She understood. This girl, this seventeen-year-old with bright blue eyes and a warm laugh, actually understood.
The waltz ended, and Lyle prepared to escort Bertha back to her friends. But the band immediately launched into a livelier number, and several other young women were looking hopefully in his direction.
"Looks like you're popular," Bertha said with a smile. "You'd better dance with some of the others, or they'll think you're not being fair."
"Oh. Yes, of course." Lyle felt oddly disappointed. "Thank you for the dance, Miss Pruitt."
"Bertha," she corrected. "And thank you, Mr. Carringer."
"Lyle," he said. "Please."
For the next three dances, Lyle danced with a succession of high school girls. One was chatty, filling the silence with gossip about classmates and teachers. Another was shy, barely speaking at all. The other was bold, asking direct questions about his work and life outside school.
But his eyes kept drifting back to Bertha. She danced with other partners—Frank Morrison and several of the high school boys who finally worked up courage to ask her. She moved gracefully, her blonde hair catching the light, her smile never fading.
During a pause in the music, Charlie appeared at his elbow. "So?" he said, grinning. "This isn't so bad, is it?"
"It's..." Lyle searched for words. "It's actually quite nice."
"I saw you dancing with that blonde. Pretty girl."
"Bertha" Lyle said. "Her name is Bertha Pruitt."
"Uh-huh." Charlie's grin widened. "And?"
"And what?"
"And are you going to ask her to dance again, or are you going to spend all night staring at her from across the room?"
…. to be continued
3) Here is the Video Overview of this post by Google NotebookLM:
4) This is historical fiction based on the facts that are available for the life and family of my maternal grandfather, Lyle Carringer. It is historical fiction based on social history and society norms at the time and place, and it is likely realistic. It might have happened this way.
5) I had to tell this story -- it leads up to his marriage and fatherhood and his life beyond Marston's.
Subscribe to receive a free daily email from Genea-Musings using www.Blogtrottr.com.
