I wondered if my AI Assistant Anthropic Claude could provide me with information about my wife's ancestral family's migration from England to Australia in 1840. My wife's 2nd great-grandparents Alexander Whittle and Rachel Morley married in 1840 and had one child at the time. I posted an ABC Biography for them in ABC Biography of Alexander and Rachel (Morley) Whittle of Lancashire, New South Wales and California (1818-1861).
I asked Anthropic Claude Sonnet 4.6 to create a description of the migration trip from Lancashire, England to Sydney, Australia experienced by the Alexander Whittle family in 1840-1841. Part 1 was published in Ask AI: "Describe Alexander and Rachel (Morley) Whittle’s Voyage on the Ship 'Brothers' in 1840-1841" – Part 1. Here is Part 2 of the story based on the biography and social history.
Alexander and Rachel (Morley) Whittle’s
Adventure – Part 2
The Voyage of the Brothers
Liverpool to Sydney, 14 September 1840 – 11 March 1841
[Continued from Part 1]
The Cape of Good Hope — 24 December 1840
They raised the Cape on the afternoon of the twenty-fourth of December, and the sight of it went through the ship like a current.Alexander was on deck when someone at the bow called out, and he turned to see the land: a great flat-topped mountain rising dark against the sky to the east, its summit trailing wisps of cloud that the locals apparently called the Tablecloth, and below it the white sprawl of Cape Town spreading down to the bay. Table Bay. The anchor went down in the late afternoon, and the
rode quietly in the shelter of the mountain while the sun went down behind it in colours Alexander had no name for — not Lancashire colours, not English colours at all, but something fierce and southern that painted the water copper and the sails gold.
It was Christmas Eve.
Someone in the between-decks had kept a small candle for this occasion, against all regulations, and they lit it after supper and set it on the communal table, and Mary Haworth sang a carol in a clear, unselfconscious voice, and then Mrs. Critchley sang one, and then the older Haworth children were persuaded to sing a third, rather badly but with great enthusiasm. Elizabeth sat on Rachel’s lap and watched the candle with absolute attention.
“Happy Christmas,” Alexander said quietly, to Rachel.
“Happy Christmas,” she said. She looked at him in the candlelight, and he saw something in her face that he recognised as the version of contentment she allowed herself in public: not happiness exactly, but the acknowledgement of it.
The candle was extinguished before Dr. Gillespie made his evening round. No one mentioned it.
They lay at anchor in Table Bay for nearly two weeks, and those days were the strangest of the whole voyage.
Cape Town in 1840 was a British colonial settlement of perhaps twenty thousand people, growing fast and prosperous on its position as the halfway house of the world. Ships from every nation lay in the bay — British, Dutch, American, Portuguese — and the town itself was a place of extraordinary variety: Dutch-gabled houses and English shops and the mountain above everything, its flat summit watching over it all. The water was clear enough to see the bottom at anchor, and the air had a dry warmth quite unlike anything they had felt in the tropics.
Some passengers were permitted ashore in small groups under the supervision of the surgeon. Alexander and Rachel went on the third day of anchorage, carrying Elizabeth and walking up from the landing through streets that were at once familiar and profoundly foreign. English shop signs, English newspapers for sale at the corner, English voices in the crowd — and then, a moment later, a flash of colour and movement that was not English at all, a world layered over a world.
They bought fresh bread, which seemed like a miracle after two and a half months of ship’s biscuit. Rachel held a loaf to her face and breathed it in. They bought oranges, a luxury that Elizabeth attacked with such single-minded enthusiasm that she was orange-coloured to the elbows for the rest of the day. They sat in a small square in the shadow of the mountain and ate the bread and the oranges and watched the street go by, and did not say much, because there was too much to say.
“Only halfway,” Alexander said at last, looking at the mountain.
“Only halfway,” Rachel agreed. Then: “But we’re here. We made it this far.”
He looked at her. She was watching a group of children playing at the far end of the square, Elizabeth in her arms watching too.
“We did,” he said.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
On the sixth of January the captain gave orders to weigh anchor.
The men refused.
Alexander heard it from below: the orders, the silence where compliance should have been, and then the raised voices. He came up on deck to find the situation worse than it had been in November. In the Cape, Captain Greyburne had procured proper irons, and this morning he would use them. The trouble, it emerged — people were talking in the between-decks, and news moved fast on a ship — was that the crew felt themselves shorthanded. Several men had jumped ship in Table Bay. The captain had proposed to make up the numbers with willing passengers; the sailors refused to accept men who were not seamen as their messmates.
What followed was ugly and slow. The prisoners — seven of them eventually, including Blandford — were put in irons. During that first night, they broke them off and threw them overboard, and the captain secured them again with chains around their middles. Some passengers were called to help work the ship while the chained men sat on the deck in the January heat, and Alexander and Tom Haworth and young Croft spent three days hauling ropes under the direction of the officers, learning the work fast by necessity.
“Not so different from the yard,” Alexander said to Croft, on the second day, coiling a hawser under instruction.
“Bigger ropes,” Croft said. He was sweating in the January sun. “More swearing.”
The prisoners were eventually released once the Brothers was well out of the bay and there was no land to swim to. They returned to their duties and gave no more trouble. Captain Greyburne did not discuss the matter with the passengers, and the between-decks discussed it constantly, in the manner of people who have had a fright and are trying to talk it into something manageable.
“We’ll be all right,” Mrs. Critchley announced, with great authority, at supper on the second night out of Cape Town.
No one contradicted her.
The Southern Ocean — January–February 1841
South of the Cape the weather changed completely and finally.
The Brothers caught the roaring forties — the great westerly winds that circled the globe at those latitudes, unimpeded by any landmass, and which were the fastest route to Australia for a sailing ship heading east. Captain Greyburne put the ship before the wind and she ran. She ran like nothing Alexander had experienced: not the slow plunging of the Bay of Biscay or the wallowing of the doldrums, but a surging, tilted, urgent rush through grey-green seas that broke white at their crests and sometimes rolled completely over the deck.
The hatches were battened down. The between-decks went dark except for the swinging lanterns. The world tilted fifteen, twenty degrees and stayed tilted, meal after meal, day after day, everything secured with lashings or wedged against the hull. The coppers swung on their gimbals. Sleeping in the berths meant wedging yourself against the side or your husband’s back, because the alternative was rolling onto the deck.
Elizabeth found this hilarious.
She was too young to understand danger and too young to be seasick for long, and she had developed the sea legs that infants sometimes find before adults, a low, wide-planted stance that rolled with the ship with something approaching elegance. She regarded the pitched and lurching world of the between-decks as a splendid game, and the Haworth children, once they recovered from their own sickness, followed her lead. The sound of children laughing in the between-decks while the ship ran before a gale in the Southern Ocean was something Alexander would not forget: incongruous and wholly sustaining.
Rachel was less philosophical.
She was not sick again — she maintained her earlier position on that subject — but the confinement wore on her. She had never been a person who liked enclosed spaces, and the battened-down between-decks, dim and loud and smelling of everything, was the most enclosed space she had ever occupied. She dealt with it by sleeping more than usual, by reading her two books through again from the beginning, and by quietly memorising the ship’s noises until she could identify each one and know what it meant.
“That’s the forestay,” she told Alexander one evening, as a particular groan worked its way through the hull above their heads.
“How do you know?”
“I asked the sailor. The young one with the red hair. He was happy to explain.”
He looked at her. “And that?” he asked, as a different sound moved through the planking.
“The mainmast partner,” she said, without looking up from her book. “It’s fine. It’s always done that.”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
There were deaths on the voyage. Old Butterworth died on the third week out of Cape Town, in his sleep, in the tilted dark of the Southern Ocean. Dr. Gillespie noted it in his log and the body was committed to the sea the following morning, the passengers gathered on deck in the grey gale-light while the captain read the words. The wind took them almost before they were said.
A child from the single-women’s quarters had died in the tropics, though the passengers in the married section had not been told until afterwards. And a baby was born in the middle of the Southern Ocean to a young Irishwoman travelling alone whose husband was already in Sydney waiting for her, and Mrs. Critchley acted as midwife with the competence of long practice, and the baby lived and was named James, and James became the most celebrated person in the between-decks for the final weeks of the voyage.
“That’s a good sign,” Mary Haworth said, regarding the new baby.
“A life for a life,” Mrs. Critchley said, meaning Butterworth.
Rachel said nothing, but she spent an afternoon rocking the Irishwoman’s baby while the mother slept, with an expression Alexander recognised as the one she wore when she was feeling something she had no intention of discussing.
Port Jackson — 11 March 1841
The pilot came aboard on the tenth of March, in the early afternoon, and the word went through the ship like fire: Australia. Land.
They had been at sea for nearly six months. For the last week the weather had been easing steadily, the great Southern Ocean swells giving way to a smoother, bluer water as they moved north into the Tasman Sea. Albatrosses had followed them since the Cape and were still there, vast and grey-winged, riding the wind above the ship’s wake as if curious to see where she was going.
The coast appeared off the port bow as a low dark line, utterly unlike anything Alexander had imagined when he tried to picture Australia. There were no mountains, no drama — just a flat, dark smudge on the horizon that slowly resolved itself into sandstone cliffs and dense green scrub and a coast that went on and on, unhurried, ancient, entirely indifferent to the small ship moving along it. The trees were wrong: wrong shape, wrong colour, their leaves the blue-grey of nothing Alexander had seen before, hanging in the still air.
“It doesn’t look like England,” Mary Haworth said.
“No,” Alexander agreed.
“Well,” she said. “I suppose that’s the point.”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
They entered Port Jackson on the morning of the eleventh of March, and the harbour opened around them like a gift.
Alexander had expected a port, a dock, something like Liverpool or Cape Town — familiar infrastructure, the business of arrival. What he had not expected was the beauty of it. The harbour was vast and intricate, a maze of headlands and coves and inlets with the water so blue it looked painted, and the town of Sydney spread up the hills on the southern shore in the morning light, its white buildings catching the sun. Green hills. Blue water. A sky of extraordinary depth.
The whole of the between-decks was on deck for the final approach. People were crying, though whether from relief or joy or the complicated emotion of having finally arrived somewhere after six months of not arriving anywhere, it was hard to say. Mrs. Critchley was not crying but her handkerchief was working hard. Young Croft was pointing at things and asking Alexander what they were, and Alexander could not answer because he had never been here either, but he pointed anyway.
Elizabeth was on his shoulders.
She had been demanding this position, with increasing persistence, for the past hour, and he had hoisted her up so she could see over the heads of the crowd at the rail. She sat there now, one hand gripping his hair with unconscious ferocity, looking at Sydney Harbour with her dark eyes wide, taking it in with the total, unembarrassed absorption of a child for whom everything in the world is still new.
Rachel stood beside him, her shoulder against his arm. She was looking at the shore.
“Well,” she said, after a long time.
He waited.
“We chose it,” she said.
He looked at her. She was still watching the shore, the white buildings rising into the green hills, the extraordinary sky.
“We did,” he said.
The Brothers moved slowly into her berth. On his shoulders, Elizabeth tightened her grip on his hair. Ahead of them, Sydney waited in the morning light, loud and new and entirely itself: the other side of the world, which was also, as of this morning, the beginning of theirs.
From the Log of the Brothers
A summary of the voyage as documented
14 September 1840. Departed Liverpool, England. 278 Bounty Immigrants aboard, including 64 from Lancashire. Crew and officers complement the vessel. Bound for the Cape of Good Hope and thence Sydney, New South Wales.
28 November 1840. Disturbance among the crew. Prisoner Blandford confined after insolence and refusing the captain’s lawful orders. Several men of the starboard watch refused to assist. Ship continues to navigate without obstruction.
24 December 1840. Arrived Table Bay, Cape of Good Hope. Anchor let down in good holding ground. Table Mountain in the offing. Christmas observed.
6 January 1841. Ordered to weigh anchor. Men refused. Prisoners — Blandford, Brandt, Smith, Williams, Northcotte, Moorcroft, Macdonald — confined in irons procured at the Cape. Passengers called to assist with the work of the ship. Vessel departed Table Bay.
11 March 1841. Arrived Port Jackson, New South Wales, at eight in the morning. All passengers and crew in health, save those noted. Anchored off Sydney Cove. The voyage complete.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Seven of the Brothers’ crew were tried at the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 13 April 1841,charged with mutiny on the high seas. Captain Thomas Greyburne gave evidence.
Alexander, Rachel, and Elizabeth Whittle settled in Sydney.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A Note to the Reader
This is a work of fiction, imagined around documented historical facts. The Brothers was a real ship that sailed from Liverpool on 14 September 1840, carrying 278 bounty immigrants including Alexander and Rachel Whittle and their infant daughter Elizabeth. The ship arrived at Port Jackson on 11 March 1841, having stopped at the Cape of Good Hope on 24 December 1840. A mutiny occurred among the crew at the Cape on 6 January 1841, the details of which are drawn from the trial reported in the Australian Chronicle of 15 April 1841. The captain’s name — Thomas Greyburne — is taken from the trial record. The descriptions of steerage life, weather, and the route are drawn from period accounts. All dialogue, characters beyond the Whittle family, and interior scenes are invented.================================
The AI Google NotebookLM Video Overview of this story is in:
This is historical fiction based on known events in the lives of my wife's ancestors -- it might have been this way. Alexander and Rachel (Morley) Whittle are my wife's 2nd great-grandparents, and I have significant information about this family from the available records, but I know nothing about their day-to-day lives.
As always, I am amazed at what life was like in any place over 180 years ago. This description of their adventure form England to Australia is interesting and so different from our current daily activities.
After I read these types of social history summaries, I wish that I could be a time traveler for one day to visit this Whittle family in 1840 abosard the Brothers and witness their daily lives. I'm glad that the general lifestyles and occupations are known from historical records and witness accounts. Fortunately, there are records and articles about this voyage -- see Mutiny on the Sailing Ship, Brothers. 1841.
Subscribe to receive a free daily email from Genea-Musings using www.Blogtrottr.com.
