Ask AI: "What Subjects Were Taught in Schools in the 1850 to 1870 Period?"

 The Artificial Intelligence tools (like ChatGPT4, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Meta, CoPilot, GenSpark, and Perplexity) can provide much useful and nearly instant information about subjects in a concise format, especially when they have been pre-trained on a large volume of information about the subjects.

1)  Several of my great-great-grandparents were born in the 1830s and 1840s and, according to census records, attended school.  I wondered about education practices in the 1850 to 1870 time frame.  What were they taught? What books were used?  What was their school day like?

My prompt to several of the free AI Tools was:  "Several of my ancestors attended school between 1850 and 1870. What subjects were taught in cities and towns in schools to small children (say 5 to 8 years old), to older children (say 9 to 12 years old), and to teenagers (say 13 to 19 years old). What books were used in each age group?  What occurred on a typical school day?"

                                               (AI image created by X Grok 3)

2)  I chose the X Grok 3 response today:

Between 1850 and 1870 in the United States, education varied significantly depending on location (urban vs. rural), socioeconomic status, and access to schools. In cities and towns, schools were more structured than in rural areas, often following a common school model that emphasized basic literacy, moral instruction, and practical skills. Below is an overview of the subjects taught to different age groups and the books commonly used, based on historical educational practices during this period. 

Small Children (Ages 5–8) 

Context: These students attend a primary class in an urban common school, typically in a single classroom with a teacher managing multiple age groups. Lessons are short, repetitive, and focused on basic skills, with oral recitation and moral instruction. 

Daily Schedule (Monday, assuming a 5-hour school day, 9:00 AM–2:00 PM with breaks): 

• 9:00–9:15 AM – Opening Exercises
  • Activity: Teacher leads students in a short prayer or moral recitation (e.g., a verse from the New England Primer) and a patriotic song (e.g., “My Country, ’Tis of Thee”).
  • Purpose: Instill discipline and moral values.
• 9:15–10:00 AM – Reading and Spelling
  • Activity: Students read aloud from McGuffey’s Eclectic First Reader, Lesson 3 (e.g., a story about a kind boy helping a bird). Teacher corrects pronunciation and explains vocabulary (e.g., “nest,” “wing”). Students spell 10 words from the lesson on slates (e.g., “boy,” “bird,” “run”).
  • Materials: McGuffey’s First Reader, slates, Webster’s Elementary Spelling Book.
  • Purpose: Build literacy and phonics skills.
• 10:00–10:30 AM – Arithmetic
  • Activity: Teacher writes simple addition problems on a blackboard (e.g., 2 + 3 = ?, 5 + 1 = ?). Students solve on slates, then recite answers aloud. Teacher introduces counting by twos (2, 4, 6, etc.) using objects like buttons.
  • Materials: Slates, chalk, everyday objects.
  • Purpose: Develop number sense and mental math.
• 10:30–10:45 AM – Recess
  • Activity: Students play outside or in a schoolyard, supervised by the teacher.
  • Purpose: Break for physical activity.
• 10:45–11:15 AM – Writing
  • Activity: Students practice copying the alphabet (uppercase and lowercase) on slates, focusing on proper letter formation. Teacher models strokes on the blackboard. Advanced students copy a short sentence (e.g., “The cat is fat.”).
  • Materials: Slates, copybooks for reference.
  • Purpose: Improve penmanship and fine motor skills.
• 11:15–11:45 AM – Moral Instruction and Recitation
  • Activity: Teacher reads a short moral story from McGuffey’s First Reader (e.g., about honesty). Students discuss the lesson (e.g., “Why is it good to tell the truth?”). Each student recites a memorized line or poem (e.g., “Work while you work, play while you play”).
  • Materials: McGuffey’s First Reader.
  • Purpose: Reinforce ethics and oral skills.
• 11:45 AM–12:15 PM – Lunch and Free Time
  • Activity: Students eat packed lunches and engage in quiet activities or play.
• 12:15–1:00 PM – Spelling and Oral Exercises
  • Activity: Teacher dictates 10 words from Webster’s Elementary Spelling Book (e.g., “dog,” “hill,” “sun”). Students write on slates and correct each other’s work. Class sings a spelling song to reinforce letter sounds.
  • Materials: Webster’s Spelling Book, slates.
  • Purpose: Consolidate spelling and auditory skills.
• 1:00–1:30 PM – Arithmetic Review
  • Activity: Students solve subtraction problems (e.g., 6 – 2 = ?, 8 – 3 = ?) on slates. Teacher uses a counting frame (abacus-like tool) to demonstrate. Students recite number facts (e.g., “Five minus two is three”).
  • Materials: Slates, counting frame.
  • Purpose: Reinforce arithmetic basics.
• 1:30–2:00 PM – Closing Recitation and Dismissal
  • Activity: Students recite a short poem or moral maxim in unison (e.g., “A place for everything, and everything in its place”). Teacher assigns homework (e.g., practice spelling five words).
  • Purpose: End the day with discipline and review.

Notes: Lessons are highly structured, with frequent transitions to maintain attention. The teacher uses oral drills and group recitation to manage a large class. Homework is minimal, focusing on memorization. 

Older Children (Ages 9–12)

 Context: These students are in a graded intermediate class in an urban common school, with a more advanced curriculum. Lessons emphasize practical skills, memorization, and preparation for civic life.

Daily Schedule (Monday, 9:00 AM–3:00 PM with breaks): 

• 9:00–9:15 AM – Opening Exercises
  • Activity: Teacher leads a prayer and a reading from McGuffey’s Third Reader (e.g., a patriotic poem). Students stand and recite the Pledge to the Flag (or a similar patriotic oath).
  • Materials: McGuffey’s Third Reader.
  • Purpose: Foster patriotism and moral focus.
• 9:15–10:00 AM – Reading and Recitation
  • Activity: Students read Lesson 12 from McGuffey’s Third Reader (e.g., a story about George Washington’s honesty). Each student reads a paragraph aloud, with the teacher correcting elocution. Students answer comprehension questions (e.g., “What did Washington do when he cut the tree?”).
  • Materials: McGuffey’s Third Reader.
  • Purpose: Improve reading fluency and comprehension.
• 10:00–10:45 AM – Arithmetic
  • Activity: Teacher introduces multiplication tables (6s and 7s) using Ray’s Arithmetic, Second Book. Students solve problems on slates (e.g., 6 × 4 = ?, 7 × 3 = ?). Advanced students tackle word problems (e.g., “If a farmer has 5 rows of 6 apples, how many apples total?”).
  • Materials: Ray’s Arithmetic, slates, blackboard.
  • Purpose: Build computational skills and problem-solving.
• 10:45–11:00 AM – Recess
  • Activity: Outdoor play or quiet indoor games.
• 11:00–11:45 AM – Grammar
  • Activity: Teacher uses Kirkham’s English Grammar to teach parts of speech (nouns and verbs). Students parse sentences on the blackboard (e.g., “The dog runs fast.”). Homework: Identify five nouns in a McGuffey story.
  • Materials: Kirkham’s Grammar, slates.
  • Purpose: Develop language structure knowledge.
• 11:45 AM–12:15 PM – Lunch
  • Activity: Students eat and socialize.
• 12:15–1:00 PM – Geography
  • Activity: Using Mitchell’s Geography, students memorize the states and capitals of the New England region. Teacher points to a map, and students name locations. Students draw a map of Massachusetts on slates.
  • Materials: Mitchell’s Geography, wall map, slates.
  • Purpose: Build spatial awareness and factual knowledge.
• 1:00–1:45 PM – Writing and Composition
  • Activity: Students write a short paragraph (3–5 sentences) on “Why I Like My Town,” focusing on neat handwriting and correct spelling. Teacher reviews Sanders’ Union Speller for common errors (e.g., “their” vs. “there”).
  • Materials: Copybooks, Sanders’ Union Speller.
  • Purpose: Enhance writing clarity and penmanship.
• 1:45–2:30 PM – History
  • Activity: Teacher reads from Goodrich’s Pictorial History of the United States about the American Revolution. Students answer questions (e.g., “Who was Paul Revere?”) and memorize key dates (e.g., 1776). Volunteers act out a scene (e.g., a town crier).
  • Materials: Goodrich’s History.
  • Purpose: Instill historical knowledge and patriotism.
• 2:30–3:00 PM – Spelling and Closing
  • Activity: Teacher dictates 15 words from Sanders’ Union Speller (e.g., “river,” “freedom,” “courage”). Students write on slates and exchange for peer correction. Class recites a poem and is dismissed.
  • Materials: Sanders’ Union Speller.
  • Purpose: Reinforce spelling and end with unity.

Notes: Lessons are more specialized, with graded textbooks allowing progression. Recitation and public performance are key, and students are expected to prepare for class exhibitions. 

Teenagers (Ages 13–19) 

Context: These students attend an urban high school or academy, with a curriculum preparing some for college and others for practical careers. Lessons are rigorous, with emphasis on rhetoric, mathematics, and classical or scientific studies. 

Daily Schedule (Monday, 8:30 AM–3:30 PM with breaks): 

• 8:30–8:45 AM – Opening Exercises
  • Activity: Teacher leads a prayer and a reading from McGuffey’s Fifth Reader (e.g., an essay by Webster). Students recite a memorized oration (e.g., Patrick Henry’s “Give Me Liberty”).
  • Materials: McGuffey’s Fifth Reader.
  • Purpose: Set a scholarly tone.
• 8:45–9:30 AM – Literature and Rhetoric
  • Activity: Students read an excerpt from Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar in McGuffey’s Sixth Reader. Teacher discusses rhetorical devices (e.g., ethos, pathos). Students prepare a short speech on “The Value of Education” for homework.
  • Materials: McGuffey’s Sixth Reader.
  • Purpose: Enhance literary analysis and public speaking.
• 9:30–10:15 AM – Algebra
  • Activity: Using Colburn’s Algebra, students solve linear equations (e.g., 2x + 5 = 11). Teacher explains factoring. Students complete 10 problems on paper, with two presented on the blackboard.
  • Materials: Colburn’s Algebra, paper, blackboard.
  • Purpose: Develop logical reasoning and math skills.
• 10:15–10:30 AM – Recess
  • Activity: Short break for stretching or conversation.
• 10:30–11:15 AM – Latin (for college-bound students) or Bookkeeping (for others)
  • Latin: Students translate a passage from Caesar’s Commentaries using Wheelock’s Latin Grammar. Teacher corrects grammar and discusses Roman history.
  • Bookkeeping: Students practice double-entry bookkeeping from a merchant scenario in a text like Bryant and Stratton’s Bookkeeping.
  • Materials: Wheelock’s Latin Grammar or Bryant and Stratton’s Bookkeeping, paper.
  • Purpose: Prepare for college or commercial work.
• 11:15 AM–12:00 PM – History
  • Activity: Using Lossing’s History of the United States, students discuss the Constitution’s formation. Teacher assigns roles for a mock Constitutional Convention debate. Homework: Write a paragraph on checks and balances.
  • Materials: Lossing’s History.
  • Purpose: Deepen civic understanding.
• 12:00–12:45 PM – Lunch
  • Activity: Students eat and prepare for afternoon classes.
• 12:45–1:30 PM – Natural Philosophy (Science)
  • Activity: Using Comstock’s Natural Philosophy, teacher explains Newton’s laws of motion with simple demonstrations (e.g., a ball rolling down a ramp). Students draw diagrams and answer questions (e.g., “What is inertia?”).
  • Materials: Comstock’s Natural Philosophy, basic equipment.
  • Purpose: Introduce scientific principles.
• 1:30–2:15 PM – Geography
  • Activity: Using Smith’s Geography, students study South American countries, focusing on resources and trade. Students label a blank map and discuss economic geography (e.g., “Why is Brazil’s coffee important?”).
  • Materials: Smith’s Geography, maps.
  • Purpose: Build global awareness.
• 2:15–3:00 PM – Composition and Grammar
  • Activity: Students write a 200-word essay on “The Duties of a Citizen,” using Quackenbos’ English Grammar for reference. Teacher reviews sentence structure and corrects drafts. Students parse a complex sentence on the blackboard.
  • Materials: Quackenbos’ Grammar, paper.
  • Purpose: Refine writing and analytical skills.
• 3:00–3:30 PM – Closing and Review
  • Activity: Students present memorized orations or debate a topic (e.g., “Should voting be restricted?”). Teacher assigns homework (e.g., algebra problems, Latin translation). Class sings a hymn and is dismissed.
  • Purpose: End with intellectual engagement.

Notes: The curriculum is demanding, with tracks for college-bound or vocational students. Public speaking and written composition are emphasized, reflecting the era’s value on oratory and civic participation.

General Observations 

• Urban vs. Rural Differences: City schools were more likely to have graded classrooms, trained teachers, and access to textbooks. Rural schools often combined all ages in one room, with fewer resources.

• Textbook Availability: McGuffey’s Readers and Webster’s Speller were nearly ubiquitous due to their affordability and widespread adoption. Other texts varied by region and school funding.

• Teaching Methods: Rote memorization, recitation, and moral instruction dominated, with limited emphasis on critical thinking or hands-on learning.

• Access and Equity: Education was not universal; poor children, girls, and minorities often had limited access, especially at higher levels. Urban schools were more inclusive than rural ones but still segregated by class and race in many cases.

• Sources:  This response draws on historical accounts of 19th-century American education, including the widespread use of McGuffey’s Readers, Webster’s Speller, and Ray’s Arithmetic, as documented in educational histories. For specific details on textbooks, I referenced standard works like The American Common School by Carl F. Kaestle and McGuffey and His Readers by John H. Westerhoff. 

3)  The Grok 3 response to the prompts was interesting and probably is accurate.  I asked the same questions of ChatGPT4, Claude, and Gemini and received similar responses.  

I liked the examples for each lesson at each grade level and the books.  The teachers had to be prepared for each day, which probably had a different lesson in each class, but from the same books.    

==============================================

Links to my blog posts about using Artificial Intelligence are on my Randy's AI and Genealogy page.  Links to AI information and articles about Artificial Intelligence in Genealogy by other genealogists are on my AI and Genealogy Compendium page.

Copyright (c) 2025, Randall J. Seaver

The URL for this post is:  https://www.geneamusings.com/2025/05/ask-ai-what-subjects-were-taught-in.html

Please comment on this post on the website by clicking the URL above and then the "Comments" link at the bottom of each post.  Share it on X, Facebook, or Pinterest using the icons below.  Or contact me by email at randy.seaver@gmail.com.  Note that all comments are moderated, so they may not appear immediately.

Subscribe to receive a free daily email from Genea-Musings using www.Blogtrottr.com.