I expressed my opinion on this issue in Thoughts on Classical and Scientific Genealogy, and then published Tamura Jones guest post in Tamura Jones Guest Post: Scientific and Traditional Genealogy, both of which generated some interesting comments from readers.
Tamura sent me a list of his related blog articles about this subject, including:
I was happy to see that Michael Hait, on his excellent Planting the Seeds blog, had written about the topic of Scientific and Traditional genealogy today.
Michael has two posts published so far:
* Traditional vs. Scientific Genealogy? (with 11 comments, including one of my own)
* Traditional vs. Scientific Genealogy, round two
* The Minnesota Family Historian blog author has this post: Scientific vs. Traditional Genealogy
* Denise Spurloc on Reflecting on Genealogy has this post: Scientific vs. Traditional Genealogy
I hope that other geneabloggers will offer thoughts and opinions about this issue. If they do, I will try to add their blog posts to this post. Please email me (firstname.lastname@example.org) or make a comment to this post so that I can add your blog post to this list.
Last updated: 22 June, 8:45 p.m.