I did this by differentiating between shared family trees (where historical persons should have just one profile) and isolated family trees (where many different trees may have the same person).
Here are my results (by exact surname, and then by tree site):
1) SEAVER surname (only this spelling):
Shared Trees:
** FamilySearch Family Tree: 8,665
** Geni.com ($$): 1,592
** WikiTree: 592
Isolated Trees:
** Ancestry Member Trees ($$): 87,523
** MyHeritage ($$): 43,468
** RootsWeb WorldConnect: 16,374
** My RootsMagic Tree: 5,283
2) CARRINGER surname (only this spelling):
Shared Trees:
** FamilySearch Family Tree: 527
** Geni.com ($$): 279
** WikiTree: 126
Isolated Trees:
** Ancestry Member Trees ($$): 13,536
** MyHeritage ($$): 5,168
** RootsWeb WorldConnect: 3,683
** My RootsMagic Tree: 212
3) RICHMOND surname (only this spelling):
Shared Trees:
** FamilySearch Family Tree: 74,239
** Geni.com ($$): 19,533
** WikiTree: 1,899
Isolated Trees:
** Ancestry Member Trees ($$): 1,324,622
** MyHeritage ($$): 437,134
** RootsWeb WorldConnect: 147,559
** My RootsMagic Tree: 115
4) AUBLE surname (only this spelling):
Shared Trees:
** FamilySearch Family Tree: 1,152
** Geni.com ($$): 437
** WikiTree: 25
Isolated Trees:
** Ancestry Member Trees ($$): 16,030
** MyHeritage ($$): 6,392
** RootsWeb WorldConnect: 2,428
** My RootsMagic Tree: 270
The major conclusions I draw from the above are that:
* FamilySearch Family Tree is probably the best Shared Tree site to search for persons with my surnames
* Ancestry Member Trees ($$) is probably the best Isolated Tree site to search for persons with my surnames
* RootsWeb WorldConnect is the largest FREE Isolated tree site available
What do your results look like?
=============================================
The URL for this post is:
Copyright (c) 2017, Randall J. Seaver
Please comment on this post on the website by clicking the URL above and then the "Comments" link at the bottom of each post. Share it on Twitter, Facebook, Google+ or Pinterest using the icons below. Or contact me by email at randy.seaver@gmail.com.
No comments:
Post a Comment